In a recent study published in PLoS Computational Biology, researchers used mathematical modelling to evaluate whether prioritizing older individuals for coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) booster vaccinations consistently leads to optimal public health outcomes across diverse socio-economic settings.
In the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic, non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) were crucial in reducing transmission and protecting healthcare systems.
The introduction of vaccines, such as those from Pfizer-BioNTech, Oxford-AstraZeneca, and Moderna, significantly altered the pandemic’s trajectory by reducing severe cases and relaxing NPIs.
However, immunity from these vaccines wanes over time, necessitating booster vaccinations, especially with emerging variants.
Further research is needed to refine booster vaccination strategies to address varying population structures and socio-economic contexts globally, ensuring the most effective public health outcomes.
About the study
The study extends a previously published age-structured compartmental model of Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) transmission and vaccination.
This deterministic model, governed by ordinary differential equations, divides individuals into compartments based on age, current infection status, and immune status before any infection.
The model includes 16 age groups, with individuals classified as Susceptible, Exposed, Infectious (symptomatic or asymptomatic), or Recovered.
To more accurately represent the time spent in the exposed class, the model employs gamma distributions, which provide a realistic representation of epidemiological periods.
The model also tracks immune status, categorizing individuals into groups such as Vaccinated, Boosted, Partially Waned, Fully Waned, and Unvaccinated, reflecting their infection and vaccination history.
The effectiveness of vaccination is incorporated into the model, accounting for reduced risks of infection, symptoms, hospitalization, and death.
Using this model, the study examines the impacts of six different age-based booster vaccination strategies across eight countries. Strategy 1 prioritizes the oldest individuals first, while Strategy 6 explores vaccinating those with the most contacts to provide indirect protection to the elderly.
Strategies 2-5 test variations of these approaches, generally focusing on prioritizing older individuals for booster vaccination. The analysis assumes limited vaccine availability, with a 10% population coverage baseline and a 90% maximum uptake per age group.
Study results
The population’s age structure varies significantly across countries, with high-income countries generally having a larger proportion of older individuals compared to low-income countries.
This demographic difference influences the distribution of booster vaccines under different vaccination strategies. In the UK, for instance, strategies 1-4 that prioritize older individuals for booster vaccination result in a substantial number of individuals aged 50-74 receiving vaccines. However, the oldest individuals (75+) may not be fully covered due to the limited vaccine supply.
On the other hand, Strategies focused on vaccinating younger individuals, particularly those aged 20-49, who typically have more contacts and, therefore, could potentially contribute to indirect protection of older populations.
However, the age distribution of vaccinated individuals under each strategy varies between countries. For example, in Sierra Leone, where the proportion of older individuals is relatively small, Strategies 1-4 effectively vaccinate almost all older individuals, leading to identical outcomes for these strategies.
This contrasts with the situation in the UK, where a larger elderly population means that not all older individuals can be vaccinated under these strategies due to vaccine constraints.
When considering the impact of these strategies on public health outcomes during a wave of infections caused by a novel SARS-CoV-2 variant, the model projections indicated that Strategy 1 consistently resulted in the fewest deaths across all countries analyzed.
This outcome is particularly evident in high-income countries, where a large proportion of older individuals contribute to a higher projected number of deaths if they are not prioritized for booster vaccination.
In contrast, in countries like Sierra Leone, the small number of older individuals allows nearly all of them to receive booster vaccines under Strategy 1, leading to fewer deaths overall.
The analysis also examined the projected Years of Life Lost (YLL), which accounts for the number of deaths and the ages at which they occur.
While it might be expected that vaccinating younger individuals could reduce YLL, the model consistently showed that Strategy 1, which prioritizes the oldest individuals, was optimal in minimizing YLL. This is due to the higher risk of severe outcomes and mortality associated with SARS-CoV-2 infection in older populations.
Sensitivity analyses further supported these findings, showing that Strategy 1 led to fewer deaths and YLL under various assumptions, including different levels of vaccine availability, uptake rates, and timing of booster administration.
Even when the outbreak began 150 days after booster vaccines were administered, resulting in some immunity waning, Strategy 1 remained the most effective approach in reducing deaths and YLL.
Conclusions
To summarize, future SARS-CoV-2 transmission will be influenced by novel variants, booster vaccinations, and immunity dynamics. Unlike the pandemic’s early stages, many individuals globally are now infected or vaccinated, impacting immunity and transmission.
In this evolving scenario, it is essential to reassess the effectiveness of past interventions and explore new strategies.
This study evaluated different age-based booster vaccination strategies and found that prioritizing older individuals consistently leads to better public health outcomes, regardless of varying population structures.
- Bouros I, Hill EM, Keeling MJ, et al. (2024) Prioritizing older individuals for COVID-19 booster vaccination leads to optimal public health outcomes in a range of socio-economic settings. PLoS Comput Biol. doi:https://doi.org/10.1371/journal. pcbi.1012309. https://journals.plos.org/ploscompbiol/article?
News
New Blood Test Detects Alzheimer’s and Tracks Its Progression With 92% Accuracy
The new test could help identify which patients are most likely to benefit from new Alzheimer’s drugs. A newly developed blood test for Alzheimer’s disease not only helps confirm the presence of the condition but also [...]
The CDC buried a measles forecast that stressed the need for vaccinations
This story was originally published on ProPublica, a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of power. Sign up to receive our biggest stories as soon as they’re published. ProPublica — Leaders at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention [...]
Light-Driven Plasmonic Microrobots for Nanoparticle Manipulation
A recent study published in Nature Communications presents a new microrobotic platform designed to improve the precision and versatility of nanoparticle manipulation using light. Led by Jin Qin and colleagues, the research addresses limitations in traditional [...]
Cancer’s “Master Switch” Blocked for Good in Landmark Study
Researchers discovered peptides that permanently block a key cancer protein once thought untreatable, using a new screening method to test their effectiveness inside cells. For the first time, scientists have identified promising drug candidates [...]
AI self-cloning claims: A new frontier or a looming threat?
Chinese scientists claim that some AI models can replicate themselves and protect against shutdown. Has artificial intelligence crossed the so-called red line? Chinese researchers have published two reports on arXiv claiming that some artificial [...]
New Drug Turns Human Blood Into Mosquito-Killing Weapon
Nitisinone, a drug for rare diseases, kills mosquitoes when present in human blood and may become a new tool to fight malaria, offering longer-lasting, environmentally safer effects than ivermectin. Controlling mosquito populations is a [...]
DNA Microscopy Creates 3D Maps of Life From the Inside Out
What if you could take a picture of every gene inside a living organism—not with light, but with DNA itself? Scientists at the University of Chicago have pioneered a revolutionary imaging technique called volumetric DNA microscopy. It builds [...]
Scientists Just Captured the Stunning Process That Shapes Chromosomes
Scientists at EMBL have captured how human chromosomes fold into their signature rod shape during cell division, using a groundbreaking method called LoopTrace. By observing overlapping DNA loops forming in high resolution, they revealed that large [...]
Bird Flu Virus Is Mutating Fast – Scientists Say Our Vaccines May Not Be Enough
H5N1 influenza is evolving rapidly, weakening the effectiveness of existing antibodies and increasing its potential threat to humans. Scientists at UNC Charlotte and MIT used high-performance computational modeling to analyze thousands of viral protein-antibody interactions, revealing [...]
Revolutionary Cancer Vaccine Targets All Solid Tumors
The method triggers immune responses that inhibit melanoma, triple-negative breast cancer, lung carcinoma, and ovarian cancer. Cancer treatment vaccines have been in development since 2010, when the first was approved for prostate cancer, followed [...]
Scientists Uncover Hidden Protein Driving Autoimmune Attacks
Scientists have uncovered a critical piece of the puzzle in autoimmune diseases: a protein that helps release immune response molecules. By studying an ultra-rare condition, researchers identified ArfGAP2 as a key player in immune [...]
Mediterranean neutrino observatory sets new limits on quantum gravity
Quantum gravity is the missing link between general relativity and quantum mechanics, the yet-to-be-discovered key to a unified theory capable of explaining both the infinitely large and the infinitely small. The solution to this [...]
Challenging Previous Beliefs: Japanese Scientists Discover Hidden Protector of Heart
A Japanese research team found that the oxidized form of glutathione (GSSG) may protect heart tissue by modifying a key protein, potentially offering a novel therapeutic approach for ischemic heart failure. A new study [...]
Millions May Have Long COVID – So Why Can’t They Get Diagnosed?
Millions of people in England may be living with Long Covid without even realizing it. A large-scale analysis found that nearly 10% suspect they might have the condition but remain uncertain, often due to [...]
Researchers Reveal What Happens to Your Brain When You Don’t Get Enough Sleep
What if poor sleep was doing more than just making you tired? Researchers have discovered that disrupted sleep in older adults interferes with the brain’s ability to clean out waste, leading to memory problems [...]
How to prevent chronic inflammation from zombie-like cells that accumulate with age
In humans and other multicellular organisms, cells multiply. This defining feature allows embryos to grow into adulthood, and enables the healing of the many bumps, bruises and scrapes along the way. Certain factors can [...]
